Selection headaches for head coach Richard Hill at Worcester Warriors

The new-look Warriors coaching team. The new-look Warriors coaching team.

THIS summer has seen perhaps the biggest overhaul at Sixways since Worcester Warriors first won their place in the top-flight of English rugby.

Not only has the club witnessed a large-scale remodelling of the playing squad, which is part and parcel of professional rugby on an annual basis, but this year there have been major changes behind the scenes too.

Nigel Redman, Phil Vickery, Mathieu Rourre, Mark Hewitt, Paul Hull and Corin Palmer have all joined the backroom team, while coaching departures have included long-serving academy boss Andrew Stanley and forward coach Phil Davies.

On the field, wingers Miles Benjamin (Leicester Tigers) and Marcel Garvey (Castres) have opted for pastures new and stalwarts such as Kai Horstmann and Dale Rasmussen were not offered new deals.

However, the arrival of Dean Schofield, David Lemi, Paul Hodgson, Nikki Walker and Jon Clarke, among many others, means Warriors now have, in my opinion, their strongest ever squad.

While the team of 2011-12 was undoubtedly talented, the strength-in-depth was not there to cover for inevitable injuries to front-line players.

That’s changed now and head coach Richard Hill will have a tough task picking his best XV.

For example, just look at his options in the second row. Many other Premiership head coaches would love to have a choice of Schofield, Chris Jones, James Percival or Craig Gillies in their boiler room.

With that in mind, I’ve ran the rule over the current squad and selected the line-up I would go with, injuries permitting, for the Premiership pipe-opener against Bath at Sixways on Saturday, September 1.

15 Errie Claassens: The full-back burst onto the scene when he joined Warriors, but suffered injury niggles. Fully fit now and was the star of the show at the JP Morgan 7s. Chris Pennell seems unlikely to be captain this term, which could leave the 15 jersey clear for Claassens.

14 David Lemi: Despite a relatively quiet couple of years in his career at Glasgow and Wasps, the Samoan ace is a proven Premiership try-scorer. Hill knows all about him from their successful time together at Bristol and they should work well together again.

13 Alex Grove: Warriors’ options at centre are more exciting now than they’ve ever been. However, despite the emphasis shifting to more attacking rugby, Grove will remain as Phil Larder’s defensive linchpin and one of the first names on the team-sheet.

12 Josh Matavesi: The Fijian Cornishman’s ball-carrying and off-loading game will be key to getting Worcester going forward. Tough to leave out Ravai Fatiaki, who impressed at the end of last term, but he will push Matavesi hard for a starting spot.

11 Nikki Walker: The Scotland international will be hoping to form a little-and-large partnership with Lemi, similar to that provided by Benjamin and Garvey. The former Ospreys winger has had injury troubles, but Hill believes those are behind him and he can be a force.

10 Andy Goode: While I feel Hill will go with Joe Carlisle as his first-choice, I’d chose Goode as Warriors usually play their best rugby when he’s in the driving seat. Fly-half will be the make-or-break position in the new-look attacking strategy and, for me, Goode is the best man.

9 Paul Hodgson: Scrum-half is a real area of strength for Warriors with Hodgson, Shaun Perry, Jonny Arr and Ollie Frost all having realistic claims. Perry struggled with a knee injury last term but, if he can fully recover from that, he will push Hodgson hard.

1 Matt Mullan: The loosehead prop will have improved even further after a place on the senior England tour to South Africa over the summer. He will also be keen to make his mark after missing out on a place in the senior EPS and being named in the Saxons.

2 Ed Shervington: Hill will rotate between Shervington’s speed around the park and line-out accuracy and Aleki Lutui’s ball-carrying prowess as and when he sees fit. However, I’d always start with the former Osprey as his line-out skills are far more reliable than the Tongan warhorse.

3 Tevita Taumoepeau: The first name on the team-sheet. While the Tongan tighthead is not getting any younger and might not cover every blade of grass on the pitch, the scrum never takes a backwards step when he’s in the three jersey, which will be vital to Worcester’s hopes.

4 Dean Schofield: The veteran lock has joined from Toulon and should be a major asset for Worcester. Renowned throughout the league as a real enforcer from his days at Sale and he also impressed in the French Top 14. Most likely contender for the captaincy too.

5 Chris Jones: A dynamic lock, who can also play number eight. An added bonus is that he played alongside Schofield for years at Sale and the duo will be eager to re-form their successful partnership, which helped the Sharks win the Premiership in 2006.

6 Sam Betty: Another really difficult call with Neil Best saying he’s in his best-ever shape and raring to go after recovering from a broken arm. However, Betty was one of the finds of the season after joining from Cornish Pirates and just about edges the battle for the blindside.

7 Matt Kvesic: Jake Abbott and Kvesic will no doubt share the number seven responsibilities and it is a tough call to pick one over the other. I have just opted in favour of Kvesic as, whenever he plays, he always catches the eye and is normally in the man-of-the-match reckoning.

8 Blair Cowan: Like Betty, another man to make the trip from Pirates to Sixways and has had just as much of an impact. He gets the nod based on last season’s performances, but I cannot wait to see what impact Tongan giant Semisi Taulava can make at this level.

Comments(14)

dulon says...
2:34pm Mon 6 Aug 12

I think that that is a good team on paper.
However this has to be turned into results
If the team are not mentally fit for purpose then they will fail. This is a management responsibility and hanging threats out in front of a player will only work in the short term. The management of the mind was a strongpoint of Sir Clive and it didnt do him any harm or the team.

zx12r says...
5:45pm Mon 6 Aug 12

I shall wait & see what the first month brings, as I think it will set the seal on the season.
Have heard through the grapevine that season ticket sales are well down on this time last season. So it would appear that the fans either don't share Mr Hill & the many coaches optimism, or they ain't going to pay the sky-high ticket prices.

Brummagem Bertie says...
10:16pm Mon 6 Aug 12

zx12r, the ticket prices are not sky high. Our ticket prices are amongst the cheapest in the Premiership. If you want sky high go to Bath or Wasps.

And if season ticket sales are down, obviously it is down to fans not believing the coaches and nothing to do with a double dip recession and people struggling to make ends meet whilst worrying if they will be next to lose their job.

dulon says...
2:00pm Tue 7 Aug 12

Bertie you do have a good point , I would be inclined to counter that argument with
the fact that we had an equal amount of spin pre season last year .And what did we get ? It was painful at times and not enough good times to balance them . If someone is going to part with hard earned cash they need to feel good about it , Me ? I will wait and see before I spend my ££££
Or maybe I will buy a season ticket for worcester wolves !

zx12r says...
9:22pm Tue 7 Aug 12

Forget the sport, my Season ticket at Villa Park, front row Trinity Road Stand is just £280 for 19 games. A standing Season ticket at Warriors is nearly that, if you can get one. The main reason for this is down to one word 'concession'.
With a £5.20 return rail fare (concession) it's still cheaper to go to Brum' than buy a ticket up the road.
I will still go to the rugby (now & again) but will follow Cornish Pirates more than Worcester because of (you've guessed it) Concessions & Penzance is a much nicer place to watch rugby than stood next to the M5.

Brummagem Bertie says...
10:02pm Tue 7 Aug 12

Standing season ticket at Warriors is £215. My ticket is £300, seated, in a covered stand.
For that I get 17 home games, get to mix with opposition supporters, rather than abused, can have a beer while I'm watching the game, and have some decent food.
I went to a game at Villa Park once. Sold out of hot food 15 minutes before kick off and only cold coke by half time. That was on a freezing Saturday afternoon. Can't think why I've never been back!

zx12r says...
1:15pm Wed 8 Aug 12

By a covered stand I assume you mean the tent that thinks it's the North Stand with umteen posts in the way.
You get 11 league games & 6 Mickey Mouse cup games, I get 19 league matches. Average price per league game for me £14.73. for you £27.27. Even my poor maths tells me that you are paying nearly double.
You know as well as me the cup games are a joke, as all clubs play understrength teams.
The beer you talk about at Sixways must be the most overpriced rubbish in the Premiership, I would not clean my teeth in it, but if getting it down your neck during a game is what turns you on, so be it.
Next, Where's this decent food you talk about. I've watched many games from the boxes & decent is not what I would call it, you only have to look at the amount that gets thrown away.
I saw my first game at Villa park in 1949 & in the 63 years since I've never been abused once. If you go looking for trouble you will find it weather it be football or rugby.
Since the American took over at Villa the club has become very much more family orientated & their charity work especially with Acorns is well documented.
The food & drink is cheaper at Villa & is passable, but I don't go there to stuff my gut & throw beer down my throat.

dulon says...
3:14pm Wed 8 Aug 12

ZX I think that you have a point there . The main reason that we go to a sporting game is .... to watch good sport . Not to throw beer down ones throat. It may be that some of the more cultured amongst us prefer to drink to excess , That is not why I go . I too have had the privilege of watching and dining in the boxes grub wasn't too bad but we were paying well !. The overwhelming opinion amongst fellow box attendees including our neighbours was of frustration and sorrow for Cecil having to put up with this embarrassment every week. He will only support the club for so long before he becomes disenchanted with the return and performance . And I don't mean a return on his capital but on his faith and trust !

zx12r says...
4:43pm Wed 8 Aug 12

dulon, Thanks for your comment. I did hear from the AGM the other night, that Dave Allen now has a 51% stake in the company, Cecil is still on the board, but who is bank rolling it is still anyones guess.

Brummagem Bertie says...
11:20pm Wed 8 Aug 12

zx12r, you presume wrong. My seat is in the South Stand, no tent, no posts.
The 3 European games are not mickey mouse. The competition is taken very seriously by all the teams taking part, as it is a route into the Heineken Cup. Watching Stade Francais at Sixways with the likes of Sergio Parisse, Roncero, Contepomi and co. was impressive. As you haven't mentioned them in your wonderful package I guess you have to pay to see Villa in footies mickey mouse competition for 2nd XIs, which used to be called the League Cup. And if you believe that watching the dross that Eck was responsible for last season represented great value for money, well, each to their own.
The beer at Sixways is not overpriced rubbish, it is award winning real ale from a local brewery, priced at 50p a pint less than I have to pay in Birmingham. Which real ale do they serve at Villa Park? And I don't pour it down my neck, but a couple of pints whilst watching the game and dissecting it afterwards with my friends helps lubricate the vocal chords a treat - essential to cheer the team on.
I don't know what food gets served in the boxes as not really keen on prawn sandwiches. I tend to swap between the faggots and the steak and ale pie, both of which are top notch and have had many favourable reviews from visiting fans.
On my one and only trip to Villa Park I did not go looking for trouble, unless you count going with some friends who were supporting the visiting side as "looking for trouble"?. Foul mouthed abuse on the way into the ground, which I quickly realised was just a warm up for even worse treatment of the visiting players. On the way out, more foul mouthed abuse, even though there were women and children in the party.
Warriors are also very much family oriented and equally do a great deal to support Acorns, St Richards, and the wider community in Worcestershire - shall we call that one a score draw?
dulon, if you think that Cecil or any of the other owners of rugby clubs do it for the return on their investment, I suggest you think again.
And it's not anyone's guess who is bankrolling the club, you just need to look at the accounts and annual return.

JTC says...
12:01am Thu 9 Aug 12

Wow such a debate.

I have a solution;

ZX you go to Villa Park my friend Jonny who is a season ticket holder for 30 years has said he will find you on the front row and buy you a pint on my behalf; he sits somewhere near you according to your description.

Bertie, I will find you in the south stand for some post match dissection and buy you a pint, whilst we do so, you have to put up with my dads opinions but I am sure you can cope.

Nothing frustrates me more than people trying to force one way of being on others, I love going to the occasional football match, Blues, Wolves, WBA, Villa, Stoke and actually enjoy the buzz.

I much prefer Sixways to those games but my godson prefers the footie, we love each other still.

dulon says...
2:31pm Thu 9 Aug 12

Bert I suggest that you read the last sentence of my comment and then consider you remark .
Cecil Duckworth has been a terrific supporter of wrfc and has in his time been a terrific employer too . The remarks about a return on his trust and goodwill have permeated the boxes for the last few years. I am, in a position as a casual supporter, able to choose where I wish to find entertainment. I might not wish to see a struggling side week in week out and might go to the basketball instead. I would not be charged to see premiership hockey male or female here in the midlands and there would be a fair smattering of our olympic stars there too . We all have the right to visit whatever we want to and, If we feel uncomfortable with one sport or team, then we can go elsewhere. It is entertainment after all and should not be an ordeal.

zx12r says...
10:09pm Thu 9 Aug 12

Well Mr Brum', we have had a bit of banter ain't we, I'm now off to Scotland on my motorcycle for a few days with some like minded people so wont be able to play for a while.
Before i go here's something even you cannot argue with....the dross I saw at Villa Park last year (I agree with you) was only matched by the dross I saw at Sixways. Please don't try & get out of this, cos' you wont be playing fair.
Be in touch soon.

Brummagem Bertie says...
10:41pm Thu 9 Aug 12

dulon, there was a reason I used the word investment, rather than capital. Perhaps you should reconsider?
zx, as for what was witnessed at Sixways last season, I was fairly realistic about what was likely. The important thing was staying up and if we had to win ugly to do it, that was fine with me. We won more than we lost and could, should, have won 3 more.
If we don't see better rugby at Sixways this season, with the new signings on and off the field, that will be disappointing.

click2find

Get Adobe Flash player
About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree